Getting duped by Israel and the American media

I’ve been duped,” declared the popular travel writer Rick Steves after watching the documentary, Peace, Propaganda, and the Promised Land.

His perception of Israel was so radically altered he felt compelled to write at the Huffington Post: “If you are a friend of Israel, you must watch Peace, Propaganda, and the Promised Land.”

The ideologically inclined are likely to read a strong political message in what Steves wrote, but my hunch is that his post was prompted by something else — an everyday concern he has as a travel writer.

Every seasoned traveler knows two things:

1. The most interesting way of experiencing another culture is through deep immersion, and
2. the most common obstacle to that experience is the tourist trade.

As a result, it’s important to get streetwise not so much because foreigners — and especially Americans — are easy targets for one kind of scam or another, but because those who profit from tourism tend to be the least faithful representatives of their own culture. That’s why, as Steves often says, the authentic experience is most often going to be found by going off the beaten track. And this quest for authenticity makes the traveler watch out for false promises.

A good travel writer has little patience for travel guides that paint deceptive pictures — where charming turns out to be tacky or a popular destination turns out to be a tourist trap.

But now, when Steves says he’s been duped, he’s describing a much higher level of misrepresentation. Israel is not the country he took it to be and their is for him a measure of insult in this discovery.

No one takes kindly to being treated like a sucker.

Rick Steves does not have a political axe to grind, but he does have a genuine appreciation of other cultures and an awareness of the degree to which most Americans are ignorant about the rest of the world.

He writes:

On the road, you learn that ethnic underdogs everywhere are waging valiant but seemingly hopeless struggles. When assessing their tactics, I remind myself that every year on this planet many languages go extinct. That means that many heroic, irreplaceable little nations finally lose their struggle and die. There are no headlines—they just get weaker and weaker until that last person who speaks that language dies, and so does one little bit ethnic diversity on our planet.

I was raised so proud of Nathan Hale and Patrick Henry and Ethan Allen—patriotic heroes of America’s Revolutionary War who wished they had more than one life to give for their country. Having traveled, I’ve learned that Patrick Henrys and Nathan Hales are a dime a dozen on this planet—each country has their own version.

I believe the US tends to underestimate the spine of other nations. It’s comforting to think we can simply “shock-and-awe” our enemies into compliance. This is not only untrue…it’s dangerous. Sure, we have the mightiest military in the world. But we don’t have a monopoly on bravery or grit. In fact, in some ways, we might be less feisty than hardscrabble, emerging nations that feel they have to scratch and claw for their very survival.

We’re comfortable, secure, beyond our revolutionary stage…and well into our Redcoat stage. Regardless of our strength and our righteousness, as long as we have a foreign policy stance that requires a military presence in 130 countries, we will be confronting determined adversaries. We must choose our battles carefully. Travel can help us understand that our potential enemies are not cut-and-run mercenaries, but people with spine motivated by passions and beliefs we didn’t even know existed, much less understand.

Growing up in the US, I was told over and over how smart, generous, and free we were. Travel has taught me that the vast majority of humanity is raised with a different view of America. Travelers have a priceless opportunity to see our country through the eyes of other people. I still have the American Dream. But I also respect and celebrate other dreams.

Facebooktwittermail

2 thoughts on “Getting duped by Israel and the American media

  1. DE Tedooru

    Traveling to Israel on my way back from a tough time in Vietnam during the war, I found Israelis most sympathetic and concerned not to leave me alone lest I suffer a “shock” moment– and these were total strangers! Yet, discussing Vietnam with Israeli intellectuals and both social and physical scientist then, I found them unmoved by the anti-Communism issue– our war they judged a crime! Yet, their kindness and concern for my personal stress reactions before I get home made Israelis unique. It was clear to me from their compassion that they knew exactly how I felt. Here I’ll stop detailing but will point out that, more than a decade later, I must say Israelis seemed gone mad. Ha’aretz wrote about how they stab eachother over a parking spot and how they “hate” eachother as much as Palestinians. The coming of the Soviet immigrants seems to have changed them and the flood of Haredi made things worst for a people by then already complaining that: “there’s no difference between the Palestinians and the Mizrahis.” Back when young Middle Eastern Jews formed the Black Panthers to obtain equality with the Ashkenazi “Nazis.”

    I still believe in the intrinsic moral Jewish character of the Israeli Sabras. Unfortunately it has no challenging targets as Israel is at a socio-economic dead end and Israelis seem to blame eachother for some reason or other. But it does seem to me that those who focused on bringing Palestinians to their level of equality and education are, paradoxically, the most happy with themselves. So, I repeat, if Israelis sought to make their place in the Middle East by promoting the modernization and integration of their Arab cousins into a common region, they could meet the challenge and feel better about being Israelis rather than despising their leaders, all the leaders with multiple passports to get out, just in case.

  2. GLOBAL INFORMATION SERVICES

    FRED AT GLOBAL INFORMATION SERVICES (WWW.GISFILMS.ORG) FORCED SAN FRANCISCO PBS STATION KQED TO AIR PEACE, PROPAGANDA AND THE PROMISED LAND ON JUNE 3, 2004 AFTER ONE YEAR OF EFFORT. SINCE THEN WE HAVE DISTRIBUTED THOUSANDS OF THIS AND MANY OTHER RELEVANT FILMS. VISIT http://WWW.GISFILMS.ORG FOR MORE INFO. LEARN HOW TO AIR THIS AND SIMILAR FILMS ON YOUR LOCAL TV STATION AND ELSEWHERE. 415-459-8738.

Comments are closed.