Why are American journalists afraid of asking #Israeli officials tough questions?

Chris McGreal writes: Here are a few questions you won’t hear asked of the parade of Israeli officials crossing US television screens during the current crisis in Gaza:

What would you do if a foreign country was occupying your land?
What does it mean that Israeli cabinet ministers deny Palestine’s right to exist?
What should we make of a prime minister, Binyamin Netanyahu, who as opposition leader in the 1990s was found addressing rallies under a banner reading “Death to Arabs”?

These are contentious questions, to be sure, and with complicated answers. But they are relevant to understanding of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict today. They also parallel the issues routinely raised by American journalists with Palestinian officials, pressing to consider how the US would react if it were under rocket fire from Mexico, to explain why Hamas won’t recognise Israel and to repudiate Palestinian anti-Semitism.

But it’s a feature of much mainstream journalism in the US, not just an issue of coverage during the last three weeks of the Gaza crisis, that while one set of questions gets asked all the time, the other is heard hardly at all.

In years of reporting from and about Israel, I’ve followed the frequently robust debate in its press about whether Netanyahu really wants a peace deal, about the growing power of right-wing members inside the Israeli cabinet opposed to a Palestinian state, about the creeping air of permanence to the occupation.

So it has been all the more striking to discover a far narrower discourse in Washington and the notoriously pro-Israel mainstream media in the US at a time when difficult questions are more important than ever. John Kerry, the US secretary of state, and a crop of foreign leaders have ratcheted up warnings that the door for the two-state solution is closing, in no small part because of Israel’s actions. But still the difficult questions go unasked. [Continue reading…]

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

One thought on “Why are American journalists afraid of asking #Israeli officials tough questions?

  1. Chet

    I find his basic premise that predominately pro-Israel coverage is something new to be incorrect. I believe the coverage has always been dominated by pro-Israel news but now it’s actually provided a little more coverage from the Palestinian perspective. Most likely due to the influence of news on the internet. The zionist propaganda can no longer withstand the scrutiny with more accurate and honest reporting originating from non-corporate media. In the past there was no Rula Jebreal or Ayman Mohyeldin even though both were initially silenced. David Gregory treated Netanyahoo like a king (King of the Jews?) and even stated, I think he issued a correction, that Netanyahoo was the leader of the Jewish people.

Comments are closed.