All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace — Part One

Adam Curtis‘ latest documentary, “All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace,” is well worth watching — all three hours — even if by its conclusion he has not neatly tied together all its disparate threads and even if his style of production has a frenetic choppiness — “I kept thinking the dog was sitting on the remote,” a reviewer joked about one of his previous pieces.

Curtis is perhaps best known as the creator of the BBC documentary series, “The Power of Nightmares,” which examined the politics of fear post-9/11.

His new documentary, just aired in the UK but presumably close to completion before the Arab uprisings began, nevertheless has relevance for every revolution across the region. The prospect of the end of dictatorial rule easily eclipses concern about what might follow — events of the present evoke a sense that the future can take care of itself. The leaderless movements currently reshaping the Arab world have organic features that sometimes seem to imply that social justice might just be a natural fruit.

But the history of self-organizing networks — a topic at the core of Curtis’ film — is that the egalitarian hopes these would-be post-political systems embody rest on an illusory foundation.

This is the story of how our modern scientific idea of nature, the self-regulating ecosystem, is actually a machine fantasy. It has little to do with the real complexity of nature. It is based on cybernetic ideas that were projected on to nature in the 1950s by ambitious scientists. A static machine theory of order that sees humans, and everything else on the planet, as components – cogs – in a system.

But in an age disillusioned with politics, the self-regulating ecosystem has become the model for utopian ideas of human ‘self-organizing networks’ – dreams of new ways of organising societies without leaders, as in the Facebook and Twitter revolutions, and in global visions of connectivity like the Gaia theory.

This powerful idea emerged out of the hippie communes in America in the 1960s, and from counterculture computer scientists who believed that global webs of computers could liberate the world.

But, at the very moment this was happening, the science of ecology discovered that the theory of the self-regulating ecosystem wasn’t true. Instead they found that nature was really dynamic and constantly changing in unpredictable ways. But the dream of the self-organizing network had by now captured our imaginations – because it offered an alternative to the dangerous and discredited ideas of politics. [Source: BBC]

Part One: Love and Power

(Watch Part Two here and Part Three here.)

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

3 thoughts on “All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace — Part One

  1. MB

    Curtis wrote — “The internet played a key role in guiding revolutions that had no guiding ideology, except a desire for self-determination and freedom…In all those revolutions, that sense of freedom lasted only for a moment. The people were brilliant at overturning the power – but then what? Democracy needs proper politics, but people have given up on saying that they’re going to change the world.” The Arab uprisings began after he finished making the films, but he sees these in the same way. “It’s as if these people assembled spontaneously on Twitter and they just want freedom. But what kind of society do they want?”

    That seems a little patronising to me — I’d say that most of the Arab revolters involved are not expecting some kind of ‘cool 1968’ hip ambience, or ‘california freak out love- in freedom’ or the levant equivalent to result from their social networking : I’d conjecture that most of the people involved ( who are over 30 ) simply see all the media tools as means to an end — and if, after the dust has settled, they choose a system of freedom which doesn’t fit in with our ideas of ‘a good result’ — well,whilst we may watch with breath held in excited aspiration, it is, in the end, their revolution.

    It appears that Curtis seems to have his own projections,hopes and perceptionS of what a revolution via technology all about , and what fruit it should bear.

    It isn’t his revolution though, is it.

  2. Colm O' Toole

    Wow I already had Century of the Self, Power of Nightmares, and What happened to Our Dream of Freedom on my hard drive but didn’t know he had a new documentary out.

    Just watched part 1 and its his normal brilliant best.

Comments are closed.