Senators say Americans would be ‘stunned’ by Obama administration’s secret application of Patriot Act

The New York Times reports: For more than two years, a handful of Democrats on the Senate intelligence committee have warned that the government is secretly interpreting its surveillance powers under the Patriot Act in a way that would be alarming if the public — or even others in Congress — knew about it.

On Thursday, two of those senators — Ron Wyden of Oregon and Mark Udall of Colorado — went further. They said a top-secret intelligence operation that is based on that secret legal theory is not as crucial to national security as executive branch officials have maintained.

The senators, who also said that Americans would be “stunned” to know what the government thought the Patriot Act allowed it to do, made their remarks in a letter to Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. after a Justice Department official last month told a judge that disclosing anything about the program “could be expected to cause exceptionally grave damage to the national security of the United States.”

The Justice Department has argued that disclosing information about its interpretation of the Patriot Act could alert adversaries to how the government collects certain intelligence. It is seeking the dismissal of two Freedom of Information Act lawsuits — by The New York Times and by the American Civil Liberties Union — related to how the Patriot Act has been interpreted.

The senators wrote that it was appropriate to keep specific operations secret. But, they said, the government in a democracy must act within publicly understood law so that voters “can ratify or reject decisions made on their behalf” — even if that “obligation to be transparent with the public” creates other challenges.

“We would also note that in recent months we have grown increasingly skeptical about the actual value of the ‘intelligence collection operation,’ ” they added. “This has come as a surprise to us, as we were initially inclined to take the executive branch’s assertions about the importance of this ‘operation’ at face value.”

The dispute centers on what the government thinks it is allowed to do under Section 215 of the Patriot Act, under which agents may obtain a secret order from the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court allowing them to get access to any “tangible things” — like business records — that are deemed “relevant” to a terrorism or espionage investigation.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

One thought on “Senators say Americans would be ‘stunned’ by Obama administration’s secret application of Patriot Act

  1. DE Teodoru

    It’s bones! Obama uses an ancient divining tool from Kenya: throwing bones and reading how they land. This is clear as any other technique would never put our war on terror into such a laughable frame! This is NOT unconstitutional as NO evidence is ever collected and used. Divined totally, the “knowledge” thus acquired is totally devoid of both legal and illegal evidence. But who can argue with success: the replacement for the World Trade Center is up 65% and no one knocked it down yet… is all glass and not one broken window!

    Viva Generalisimo Obama with the Hawaiian “notice of Birth”!!!

Comments are closed.