Israel’s vain quest for sovereignty

Why is it that a country that defines itself in terms of existential threats and the need to provide a safe refuge for the Jewish people, nevertheless seems strangely remiss in securing its own autonomy?

Even if Israel stands out as the preeminent military power in the Middle East, it has only been able to acquire this status through its dependence on the United States. It often masks that dependence by behaving like a brash teenager who is secretly terrified by the thought of leaving home.

Last week, Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, the former Sephardi Chief Rabbi of Israel and spiritual leader of the Shas party — part of Netanyahu’s ruling coalition — made his latest inflammatory statement. In August Yosef called for the annihilation of the Palestinian people. This time he showed his contempt for humanity — at least that rather large portion which happens not to be Jewish, the Goyim.

Goyim were born only to serve us. Without that, they have no place in the world; only to serve the People of Israel …Why are gentiles needed? They will work, they will plow, they will reap. We will sit like an effendi [lord] and eat…

Yosef’s comments and the lack of censure they received from Israeli politicians, drew swift criticism from the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) Director Abraham Foxman and David Harris, executive director of the American Jewish Committee. Foxman warned that this might have a detrimental effect on Israel’s relations with American Jewry.

While leaders of the American Jewish community acknowledged the damage Yosef’s words could cause, they did not attempt to analyse them.

The Israeli-born anti-Zionist activist and musician, Gilad Atzmon suffers no such reservations.

In just a few words Rabbi Yossef expresses the depth of Judaic contempt towards labour.

The senior Rabbi provides us with a devastating glimpse into the Judaic alienation from these aspects of the human condition and human experience. In an unequivocal manner, Rabbi Yosef depicts a clear dichotomy: Jews are the master race and the Goyim are nothing but a work force. The Goyim are there to sweat and struggle while the Jew is ‘sitting’ and ‘eating.’ I guess that Rabbi Yossef has managed, in just a few words, to portray the intrinsic relationships between Judaism and Capitalism.

But in fact, Rabbi Yossef didn’t invent anything new here — his Saturday sermon sounds familiar enough to me. Karl Marx in his paper “On The Jewish Question,” identified aspects of Jewish ideology at the heart of Capitalism: “It is mankind (both Christians and Jews) that needs to emancipate itself from Judaism.”

Marx managed to identify an inclination towards exploitation at the heart of Jewish culture.

However, being a humanist, Marx wanted to believe that mankind (Jews and others) could overcome this tendency. Many early Zionists too, were also convinced that in Zion, Jews would liberate themselves and eventually become a nation like other nations, through productivity and labour.

Seemingly though, Rabbi Ovadia Yosef is not that impressed with either Marx, or some of the ideals within the early Zionist dream: Rabbi Yossef is brave (or foolish) enough to sketch the inherent bond between Jewish culture and Capital.

The only question that is still open is, for how long can the rest of humanity tolerate that kind of Rabbinical arrogance?

Meanwhile, the publication of a “millionaire’s list” last week, revealed Netanyahu’s complete dependence on foreign money for his fundraising efforts. His office in an attempt to explain his donor preferences released a statement in which they made the implausible claim: “His approach is that funds should be raised abroad so as not to put anyone in a potential conflict of interests, and this is the reason he prefers donations from abroad.”

On Capitol Hill, U.S. Rep. Eric Cantor, the Republican whip and the only Jewish Republican in the House of Representatives, is concerned that a GOP-led Congress which aims to cut foreign aid could make Israel vulnerable, since it receives more aid than any other country. A possible solution would be that aid to Israel be part of the US defense budget, adding new meaning to the idea that Israel and US interests are indivisible.

Israel demands that it be recognized as a Jewish state by the Palestinians. “Affirmation of Israel’s Jewishness…, is the very foundation of peace, its DNA,” says Israel’s ambassador to the US, Michael Oren. Yet in the shadow of this fixation on Jewish identity, we see a singular lack of interest in autonomy expressed through a religious leader’s contempt for work, a prime minister’s appetite for foreign money, and a Congressman’s concern that the umbilical chord tying Israel to the US not suffer any interruption or constriction in the steady supply of US tax dollars required for supporting the Jewish state.

Where in this condition is any understanding of the real meaning of sovereignty? Might not Israel’s greatest existential threats be the ones of its own making?

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

10 thoughts on “Israel’s vain quest for sovereignty

  1. pabelmont

    “Yet in the shadow of this fixation on Jewish identity, we see a singular lack of interest in autonomy expressed through a religious leader’s contempt for work, a prime minister’s appetite for foreign money, and a Congressman’s concern that the umbilical chord tying Israel to the US not suffer any interruption or constriction in the steady supply of US tax dollars required for supporting the Jewish state.”

    The author suggests (as does the Rabbi’s very clear and unambiguous formulation) that the Jews own the world (or, put another way) the world owes the Jews a living. Masters and slaves. (Spoiled teenagers of wealthy parents? Some of them never grow up. Never. And the occupation continues * * *).

  2. Kate Seley

    The fact that one of the early goals of Zionism was that “Jews would liberate themselves and eventually become a nation like other nations through labour” is illustrative of the positive, idealistic side of the original Zionist project. This side existed but it has been dying since the Occupation, if not before. Now the only hope for peace is probably through a peaceful one-state solution and Israel’s integration into the Middle East. Israel has probably missed its opportunity for a 2-state solution. This something the philosopher Martin Buber already foresaw in the early 60’s. What is needed is a Palestinian Mandela. Perhaps Barghouti?

  3. scott

    This certainly affirms that very narrative–like an adolescent bucking about restraints of dependency and unable to live on their own–something about biting the hand that feeds.

    “MK Michael Ben-Ari wrote to United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon on Monday to urge him to form a probe to investigate the actions of the American military in Iraq that the WikiLeaks web site alleged were war crimes.”

    “Ben-Ari suggested that the probe be headed by Judge Richard Goldstone, who investigated Israel’s handling of Operation Cast Lead in the Gaza Strip.”

  4. delia ruhe

    Well, Gilad Atzmon knows more about this than I do, so I’ll have to take his word for it. But he sounds a bit Oskar Weininger to me. As someone who grew up among Jews, read Chaim Potok and Sholem Aleichem as a teenager, lived in New York, have close friends among Jews, have had Jewish lovers, lived with a Jewish family while I was in grad school, I would have to say quite the opposite. When I was in Israel on sabbatical I was surprised at how few Jews there were there. That is to say, Israelis are the most un-Jewish Jews I’ve ever met. If I were a non-Israeli Jew, I would be up in arms over the fact that Israel wants to be recognized as a Jewish state, because that is a gross insult to Jews everywhere else. In sum, I never confuse Israelis with real Jews.

  5. John Somebody

    I have found the most dedicated anti – zio activists, that I have come across, in England, to have been from a Jewish background. That was three people. I know around 20 active members of Jews for Justice. As a group, they decide not to picket outside a local zionist store, because that, “might be perceived as being anti Jewish”. This even though campaigning against Israel might be perceived in that way. But the people I have found to be the most rabid hypocrite racists, in the greatest numbers, after nearly 30 years of across the spectrum campaigning, up an down this country, remain those who claim to be Jewish.
    I understand something of the difference between real Jews, and imitation ones. But if there’s such a difference between Israeli Jews, and the diaspora, why do so many of the latter support such a society and state, which depends on racism to exist ?

  6. Christopher Hoare

    I’d suggest that Rabbi Yosef’s statements need to be disseminated much more widely. We poor goyim need to be aware of our proper place in the world. Perish the thought that we may inadvertently in contravention of our limited purpose.

  7. CompassionateFascist

    In sum, Jewish racial nationalists, aka Zionist-Israelis, have succeeded in reifying both principal historical accusations of “anti-semites”: collective parasitism (i.e., Israel itself, on America) and subversive Tribal loyalty (the majority of “American” Jewry, to Israel). Nice job. Thanks.

  8. Renfro

    Rabbi Yosef’s reminds though what my sister in law said about zionism some years ago…that’s it’s a ‘cult’. She’s a psychiatrist affiliated with a major hospital and treats those mentally disturbed enough to require hospitalization. I’ll have to mail her the Rabbi’s declarations and see if she can give me the proper clinical term for their mental condition.

  9. Lionyouth

    Gilad Atzmon’s writing goes from heights to heights these days — he has written some really perceptive articles in recent months.

  10. eddy mason

    It’s Israel that needs a Mandela, to stop them from destroying themselves from within! And it will be the world’s goyim who will have to clean up the mess, again.

Comments are closed.